The Cheese Lady has an impressive selection of over 200 artisan cheeses from all over the world. Explore our offerings below and learn more about every variety. Availability will vary, so please call ahead or order online for store pickup if you are looking for something specific.
If spice is your style, it’s worth giving this fiery cheddar from Milton Creamery a try. Chipotle, chili, jalapeno and ghost peppers are blended into a young cheddar, which serves as a sweet and creamy base for an intensely hot, richly spiced burst of flavor. Perfect for those who love a bit of heat but don’t want to sacrifice the flavor of the peppers! Try it melted on a burger or mixed into chili for a hearty and warming meal, or slice it with salami and apples.
Made in Vermont. Alpha Tolman has a buttery, fruit & nut flavor when young, developing bold meaty, caramelized onion flavors as it matures. The texture is dense and pliant, easily portioned and ideal for melting. Alpine cheeses like Appenzell inspire the recipe for this Jasper Hill Creamery original.
Appenzeller cheese from Switzerland is a 700-year-old cow’s milk cheese, distinct for its straw color and nutty flavor, each dairy using a unique herbal brine. From France, Fromager d’Affinois is a creamy brie-style cheese with a fresh pea-pod taste, ideal with crackers. Melkbus raw milk Gouda, especially the truffle-infused Melkbus 149, is a buttery Dutch cheese. Ossau-Iraty, an ancient AOC sheep’s milk cheese from the French Pyrenees, is renowned for its deep, buttery flavor.
In Armenia, traditional string cheese includes black cumin (scientific name Nigella Sativa) and a Middle Eastern spice known as mahleb, and it comes in the form of an endless loop. The cheese forms strings because of the way it is pulled during processing. Other cheeses are only cut and pressed, not pulled, and don’t develop strings.
Heralded as the ‘dew of the sea’ Rosmarinus officinalis provides the perfect savory high note for this rich, nutty and fruity taste sensation. A gold-medal winner of the 2008 World Championship Cheese Contest, this extraordinary delight wears its laurels as lightly as the perfect balance of hand-rubbed rosemary and Italian olive oil.
This artisan cheese has been aged for over four years in our select Dutch aging rooms. It has a stunning complex flavor. It is nutty with flavors of caramel. This cheese adds a great touch when grated over spinach salad, pizza or pasta. It also makes fabulous risotto and omelets.
We have been making cheese on our farm in Ditcheat, Somerset for six generations. Made using traditional starter cultures, rich milk from our cows, and always matured for at least 24 months, Barber’s 1833 Vintage Reserve Cheddar is the culmination of all our achievements. A deliciously creamy cheese with both savory and naturally sweet notes. Only the very best leaves with the 1833 stamp.
Crafted in the traditional method of aging in beech tree barrels, this 4 month old Feta is made with sheep and goat milk. The barrel aging lends this delightful cheese a robust, tangy, and sweet flavor complimented by a crumbly-creamy texture. Perfect to crumble up over a salad for an amazingly rich boost!
Inspired by the sheer natural beauty of our coastal climate and locale, Bay Blue is a rustic-style blue cheese with a natural rind. It is known for its mellow flavor and sweet, salted caramel finish.
The unique blue sea clay soil of the Beemster polder contains special mineral and therefore special grasses which makes the fat softer and sweeter than other milk in the Netherlands. Aged for 4 months, it’s smooth and sweet with a wonderful clean finish. Another great Dutch Gouda.
Dutch cheesemaker, Beemster, makes this young cow’s milk Gouda, infused with wild garlic. A garlicky, creamy cheese from the Netherlands.
Beemster X-O-, aged for 26 months, is Beemster’s oldest cheese. Its unique milk enables a wide flavor range in a shorter aging time, maintaining a smooth, creamy taste, unlike longer-aged cheeses that become crumbly and granular. Perfectly paired with port wines and sweet whites like Riesling, X-O- also serves as a great Parmesan alternative for pastas.
Inspired by a traditional Italian farmstead cheese, Bella Vitano Gold combines the fruity flavor of a premium Parmesan with the creamy smoothness of fine Cheddar. It won a Gold Medal at the 2008 World Cheese Awards.
Espresso BellaVitano is one of the award-winning cheeses in the Sartori Reserve product line. This gourmet cheese is a delicious treat for your breakfast or dessert. Freshly roasted espresso is hand-rubbed into sweet, sugary BellaVitano wheels aged to creamy perfection. The cheese received a Silver Medal in the 2010 World Cheese Awards and a 3rd place in the 2011 American Cheese Society Competition. It pairs well with Pinot Noir, Shiraz, Merlot and Chardonnay or with your fruit beers, stout, Porter beer, Trappist style ale or Barley wine. Food pairings are also multiple, how about chocolate, dried fruit, sweet pastries, honey.
This classic, French-style cultured cream has a rich, nutty flavor with an appealing tart edge. A basic pantry item in French kitchens, it is an ingredient used by fine cooks in many cuisines. Pour over fruit, whip into soups, stir into sauces. Creme Fraiche never curdles while cooking.
This spicy hand-rubbed cheese packs a heated punch as you near the rind. Made from the milk of local Jersey cows in Northern Utah, the combination of sweet creaminess and spice make it a great addition to any cheese plate. The spice is right! The Cajun rub was developed by local Ogden, UT chef John Dearmin using only the finest ingredients. Unlike typical Cajun rub, Big John uses cayenne pepper instead of paprika. Sorry, the rest of the recipe is top secret. The spiciness of the rub is a nice compliment to the creamy texture of the cheese. Watch out, this cheese packs a heated punch as you near the rind.
In 1845 Antoine Roussel, the son of a farmer from the Auvergne region, had the idea to seed his milk-curd with a blue mould he had seen developing on rye bread. He then pierced his cheese with a needle and Bleu d’Auvergne was born. This A.O.C. cheese from south-central France is a favorite of ours.
Made using a recipe in which five ten-gallon cans of cream are added to each vat, The Blue Jay is rich in texture with strong buttery notes. We then crush juniper berries to release their perfume and infuse them throughout to complement the Blue strain’s unique botanical essence. The result is a bold, yet utterly creamy Blue with a delicately piney bouquet that blooms in your mouth.
Though it has origins in Scotland, the dairy that first made Shropshire Blue was sold and the cheese production was moved to Nottinghamshire, England where Stilton is made. Blue Shropshire is full fat, full flavoured and un-pressed. Annatto turns this cheese yellow with distinctive blue veining. Cheddary and blue ,We love it!
By soaking each wheel of cave-aged blue cheese in an organic red wine blend, we create a cheese with distinctive berry notes and a brown butter finish , in addition to a subtle rose blush coloring on the rind.